Brendan's Feedback on Alexis' Post: Constructs of Femininity and Masculinity Portrayed in Desperate Housewives
Having never seen Desperate Housewives, this review makes the show seem  almost as terrible as the one I wrote my post on!  You did an excellent  job selecting a show and episode that could be analyzed within the  constructs of masculinity and femininity.  The entire story goes from  bad to worse to horrible as the female depiction becomes more  stereotypical with each passing moment.  It was perfect how the readings  we have been studying fit exactly into the depiction of femininity on  the episode.  The overall ideas presented by the readings you chose  worked well by providing evidence for your analysis.  Gabrielle making  the ultimate sacrifice by attending the event "ugly" and "naked" seems  almost outrageous when I'm reading your post about it.  I'm sure when  watching the episode and zoning out it may be easier to not realize how  absurd this episode really is.   
One thing you might have been  able to improve upon was the overall structuring of the post.  Instead  of making one point and then backing up the point with evidence, it  seemed that you made multiple points in a few paragraphs and then did a  few paragraphs of analysis afterwords.  It just made it slightly harder  for me to follow.  I had to skim upwards a few times to make sure I knew  exactly which part of the show you were referring to.  Overall great  job!  It was a perfect episode and your analysis was spot on.

No comments:
Post a Comment